|
Post by raymondo on Jun 14, 2011 8:24:31 GMT -5
Rebsie's marvellous red podded pea seems to have inspired a number of people to have a go at creating their own, me included. I hope those interested find the following useful. There is one gene at work for the green vs yellow pod and there are, it seems, three genes at work for the purple pod, an on/off switch plus two colour genes. Lets call them A, B, C for the purple and D for the green. If all three purple genes need the dominant alleles (I'm not 100% sure about this), a true breeding purple must be AABBCCDD, that is, homozygous dominant at all four loci. A true breeding yellow could have a number of genotypes but the worst case scenario for a breeder interested in creating red pods would be aabbccdd, that is, all homozygous recessives. So, the first cross, in the worst case scenario, is a cross of homozygous dominants for all four genes (purple) and homozygous recessives for all four genes (yellow) - AABBCCDD x aabbccdd. This means that the F1 generation will be heterozygous for all four genes and all purple podded - AaBbCcDd. This exactly what Rebsie found ( daughterofthesoil.blogspot.com/2008/03/real-seeds-purple-mangetout-pea-project.html). For the F2, a Punnett square is way too messy as it will have 16 (4 genes each with 2 alleles or 2 4) possible gametes producing no less than 256 possible zygotes. Instead, let's calculate the probability of getting a red-podded pea in the F2. You want at least one dominant allele in each of the three purple gene slots and you want both recessive alleles in the green pod slot. The probability of getting at least one dominant is 3/4 at each of the purple slots. The probability of getting both recessives in the green slot is 1/4. So, the total probability of getting a red pod is 3/4 x 3/4 x 3/4 x 1/4 = 27/256. So, 27 out of your 256 possible outcomes will have red pods. That's a little more than 10% which is pretty good. Of course, most of these will be heterozygous at one or more of the purple pod slots so in subsequent generations you'll get plenty of yellows showing up. You'll need to do some family line selections to eliminate the recessives here. You won't have to worry about green pods showing up because all the F2 reds that you started with will be homozygous recessive in the green slot. All of the above assumes independent assortment. Then of course there's the issue of pod type - shell/snow/snap! The way I intend to go is to do deliberately what Rebsie did by chance. At the same time that I do my purple/yellow cross, I'll do a green/yellow cross looking for a better yellow. Then, if needs be and I have to cross the red into a yellow to get the right pod type, I should have a good one to use. I hope this helps rather than hinders.
|
|
|
Post by keen101 (Biolumo / Andrew B.) on Jun 14, 2011 9:42:18 GMT -5
Looks pretty good to me Ray.
Although, perhaps Rebsie had slightly better odds because she made sure that both the purple podded parent and Golden Sweet both had colored flowers, which means that each parent had at least 1 dominant A gene. Picking a yellow podded variety that has coloured flowers would be most helpful. From what i've read from rebsie's review of Opal Creek is that her Opal Creek line had white flowers, so there is at least one yellow variety out there without the dominant A gene.
Yeah, that's what i was thinking as well. Once you have a red podded one, it would be easier to breed it with a yellow podded type or even a purple podded. The problem is that there are few really good edible yellows and purples available, so most of us might want to consider breeding better varieties of those at the same time.
|
|
|
Post by Joseph Lofthouse on Jun 14, 2011 12:32:47 GMT -5
To me, working with recessive genes is the best possible scenario. Because once you find a plant containing a set of the recessive genes you are done with the breeding project. If you are working with dominant genes you have to grow out generation after generation of plants to weed out the hidden recessive genes.
|
|
|
Post by raymondo on Jun 15, 2011 2:57:54 GMT -5
Yes, there are a number of scenarios that would make things go quicker, though being on the same chromosome may not necessarily be one of them. It has been found that if genes are more than 50cM apart on the same chromosome, they behave as if they are on different chromosomes during meiosis, that is, they will assort independently. (A cM is a centiMorgan, one name for the unit of distance on along a chromosome. They are also called mu or map units.)
Is one of the purple genes required in a recessive form? If that's the case my maths needs to change. In the F2, you'd only get 9 out of 256 with red pods, not 27. Not as attractive but still, not bad. If I didn't get any reds in my F2, I'd grow out lots of the purples because some may be heterozygous at the green pod locus so there's a chance of getting red in the F3. I'd also be doing the original cross each year and growing out the F1 the following year always on the lookout for a red. One should turn up sooner or later.
|
|
|
Post by Joseph Lofthouse on Jun 15, 2011 12:35:26 GMT -5
Is one of the purple genes required in a recessive form? If that's the case my maths needs to change. Edited on 2011-06-15 to correct my error. To get purple pods: One Pur (dominant) and one Pu (dominant) have to be present (Plus at least one A [dominant - linked to Pur], plus the genes for green pod. ) Red pods require the purple genes plus the genes for yellow pod.
|
|
|
Post by keen101 (Biolumo / Andrew B.) on Jun 15, 2011 16:07:17 GMT -5
To get purple pods: One Pur (dominant) and two pu (recessive) have to be present (Plus at least one A [dominant - linked to Pur], plus the genes for green pod. ) Red pods require the purple genes plus the genes for yellow pod. Joseph, you wouldn't happen to have a link that tells about the pu gene needing to be recessive do you? So, the "A" gene is the master color switch gene, the "Pur" gene is the gene for purple flowers, and the recessive "pu" gene is for purple pods?
|
|
|
Post by Joseph Lofthouse on Jun 15, 2011 21:36:25 GMT -5
Joseph, you wouldn't happen to have a link that tells about the pu gene needing to be recessive do you? Sorry about my misunderstanding. Pu for purple pods is dominant when the other genes necessary for it's expression are present. I misread an article months ago and it's been causing me to post errors ever since.
|
|
|
Post by raymondo on Jun 16, 2011 3:17:27 GMT -5
So, three dominants, two of which are linked, and one recessive. That does make it easier to find reds. Thanks Joseph. Of course, you still have to weed out the recessives that come in from the yellow podded parent, but you can be systematic about it and do it in 'family' lines. Still takes a while but all that while you're eating red podded peas. If the linkage was total, that is if A and Pur always segregated together, then the probability of finding a red pod in the F2 would be 36/256. But that's not usually the case. Linked genes usually only segregate together some of the time. The probability of finding a red pod in the F2 with the above scenario is somewhere between 27/256 and 36/256. Either way, there's a good chance of getting a red pod if you grow out enough F2s, and enough would be something like 50. With only 50 plants you'd be more than 99% sure of finding at least one red podded plant.
|
|
|
Post by Joseph Lofthouse on Jun 16, 2011 22:30:08 GMT -5
It's too late for me this year to attempt breeding peas, but before my interest in red pods was aroused, I happen to have planted a purple podded pea. I'm looking forward to sharing seed in about August. As of today they have made it this far:
|
|
|
Post by raymondo on Jun 17, 2011 5:15:54 GMT -5
Attractive enough for the ornamental garden!
|
|
|
Post by keen101 (Biolumo / Andrew B.) on Jun 18, 2011 22:31:21 GMT -5
It's too late for me this year to attempt breeding peas, but before my interest in red pods was aroused, I happen to have planted a purple podded pea. I'm looking forward to sharing seed in about August. How come it's too late for you joseph? Half of my peas haven't even bloomed yet. Are all your flowers gone? I tried a cross the other day with a golden sweet as the mother, but i don't know what color the pods from the other will be. Hopefully it was a purple podded one, but it might just have been a green. I had mixed all my seed together, so it's been hard to tell the varieties apart before seeing the pods. Next year i will mark different rows. It was surprising how early you have to catch the flowers, and they are smaller at that stage than i expected. I will definitely need a tiny pair of scissors or a really sharp scalpel. but, the good news is that I'm finally starting to see some nice pods. I should at the very least get enough seed to work with for next season.
|
|
|
Post by Joseph Lofthouse on Jun 22, 2011 9:27:46 GMT -5
Great looking yellow pod. How come it's too late for you joseph? Half of my peas haven't even bloomed yet. Are all your flowers gone? My March planted peas are just starting to bloom. I don't have suitable genetics for attempting a red podded pea this summer. And by the time I obtained seed and planted it I expect that the remaining growing season would be too hot for them to thrive. The best I expect to do this year is to attempt to transfer the purple pod gene into a snap pea, which I think I will try, even though the parents are growing in gardens 20 miles apart... I typically plant peas in March or April. I tasted snap peas for the first time last summer. Oh my gosh!!!! I was very impressed with them!
|
|
|
Post by 12540dumont on Jun 22, 2011 12:19:29 GMT -5
Joseph, what kind of snap peas are you growing?
|
|
|
Post by Joseph Lofthouse on Jun 22, 2011 13:52:57 GMT -5
Joseph, what kind of snap peas are you growing? I don't know... They came from Mountain Valley Seed out of Salt Lake City. Based on their current catalog, and the 4 foot tall already vines, I'd guess that they are the original "Sugar Snap"
|
|
Hawk
gopher
Posts: 22
|
Post by Hawk on Nov 26, 2011 14:39:11 GMT -5
Rebsie, Thank you for posting this thread. With the encouragement of a few friends ( ) I have begun breeding tomatoes this year. I made 10 crosses this year that set fruit. I have my F1's in the greenhouse right now. I am seeing successful confirmation in some of the F1 phenotypes. I will have to wait to see the others when the fruit has set or ripens. I am looking forward to this next garden season. I would like to try my hand at breeding to improve tomatoes, peppers, cucumbers, melons, squash and more! I love to garden and watch stuff grow. I really enjoy the good and wholesome food for my family! I am a seed saver and I like to share seeds. The greenhouse and the garden is a good place for me to find my zen. After reading this thread I am eager to work with edible pod peas. I have read that the sugar snap pea arrived from a cross between the garden pea and the edible pod pea. Is this the case? Thank you, Jason
|
|